Category Archives: Rav Avraham Yitzchak Kook

Video documentary of Rav Kook

While searching on the Merkaz HaRav English website under their Video section, I came across this video documentary of Rav Kook. Click here to view it. 

Rav Kooks Educational Philosophy Part 3:

Chardal has posted an interesting letter from Rav Kook outlining a curriculum of texts and ideas that he felt needed to be incorporated into the educational framework. See the letter here.



Rav Kook as a young man as Rabbi of Zoimel (Date of Picture probably 1888+, Rav Kook would be in his mid 20’s based on this timeline)



Thoughts On Love From Rav Kook – Part 1

One of my favourite seforim by Rav Kook is "The Moral Principles" (In Hebrew: Midot Harayah). It is published in english by Ben Zion Bokser in "Abraham Isaac Kook: The Lights of Pentience, Lights of Holiness, The Moral Principles, Essays, Letters, and Poems" as part of "The Classics of Western Spirituality" series.

Below is a the first excerpt from the chapter entitled “Love” from this sefer (Pg 135). More will be coming, so stay tuned.

LOVE
1) The heart must be filled with love for all

2) The lovel of all creation comes first, then comes the lovel for all mankind, and the follows the love for the Jewish people, in which all other loves are included, sinice it is the destiny of the Jews to serve toward the perfection of all things. All these loves are to be expressed in practical action, by pursuing the welfare of those we are bidden to love, and to seek their advancement. But the highest of all loves is the love of G-d, which is love in its fullest maturing. This love is not intended for an derivative ends; when it fills the human heart, this itself spells man’s greatest happiness.

3) One cannot but love G-d, and this sweet and necessary love must engender as a practical consequence an active love for everything in which we perceive the light of G-d. One cannot but love the Torah and the commandments, which are so intimately linked to the goodness of G-d. One cannot but love equity and righteousness, the bening order that engenders good for all, which is firmly linked to the reality of existence, and in which the heart envisions excellence, that, becaue of its majesty and beauty, we designate as the will of G-d. The divine will is manifest in it, but it is greater than all this, and distinct from all this, and it nourishes the soul of every living being which delight beyond anything to which thought could reach. And it is impossible not to be filled with love for every creature, for the flow of light of G-d shines in everything, and everything discloses the pleasantness of the Lord. “The mercy of the Lord fills the earth” (Ps 33:5)

Rav Kooks Educational Philosophy Part 2

The following is an extract of a letter written by Rav Kook To Rabbi Yizhak Isaac Halevi (To the best of my knowledge this is the author of the Dorot Harishonim). It outlines what for Rav Kook is the the essence and ultimate goal of all Jewish education, to know and to love G-d. If one does not achieve that, then the end result is apathy and estrangement from Torah and the Jewish people.


By the grace of God, Rehovot, 4 MenahemAv, 5668 [1908]


From narrow places, He who illumines the world and all its inhabitants will raise a light of deliverence. To the renowned rabbi, our pride and source of strength, whose name is adorned with holiness, our master Rabbi Yizhak Isaac Halevi, may he be blessed with a long and good life, peace, peace with much love…

We cannot ignore all the bitter complaint voiced by the great spirits of the world, the Cabbalists, the philosophers, moralists and the pietists, over our neglect of the spiritual dimension of our faith. The essence of this complaining is already found in the torah, in the prophetic and the later writings, and among all the sages of the Talmud. The knowledge of God, his love, and the higher level of his fear, which are merged with responsiveness to life in its fullness that is renewed each day – this is the foundation of all life. It is the basic objective of the Torah and the commandments, of the entire Talmud, and the halakha [the corpus of law]. When this is the present everything is present. What inspired the heretics to reject the principles of faith and to subvert its teachings by repudiating the Cabbalah, is in its essence the fact the world has grown even darker, from generation to generation, through the withdrawal of the inner light that is transmitted through the spiritual channels. The decline in knowledge [of God] has led to a decline in love for hi,; because feeling has run dry, love has ceased; and because there has been a decline of love, heresy has emerged to undermine the expressions of piety that have become a burden. It could only accomplish this by sinister rejections and ignorance. If the love had continued through the holy sensibilities of the person, and his attachment to the light of the Torah, through the power of spiritual reflection, which is joined with the broad and profound domain of the practical halackha, this state of affairs would never have come to pass….

I am not saying that all the students of the Yeshiva are to be great scholars in all fields. This is impossible. Some special individuals may be born with such talents, that they can absorb everything, but the majority divide into specialists and a person can only master that to which his heart is drawn. In its general orientation, however, the Yeshivah must give our people all that it lacks. And since in our time, among the subjects to which people are drawn and which have a great impact on life is literature and poetry, we must also see that in this field, too, we shave have our own, and it shall no longer be a fact that every talented person in the field of literature and every prominent poet must automatically be a heretic and a sinner. We must destroy this false assumption and show the world that the beauty of poetry and the delights of literature will flower when they are rooted in the life of our people, in its natural state, when it is faithful to a past whose source is the living water of faith in God.

Igrot I, Letter 149

Rav Kooks Educational Philosophy Part 1:

I recently bought a wonder book entitled “The Essential Writings of Abraham Isaac Kook” by Ben Zion Bokser. It is an incredible book that translates many important essays, letters and quotations from R’Kook into simple to read English.

Here is a letter where R’Kook decries the sorry state of Judaism in the Holy Land, in his opinion due to curriculum of Yeshivot at his time. He saw a generation of disenchanted youth, who were not being revitalized by the pilpul of Talmudic dialectics. He wanted to renew the inner soul and life force of these youth, by providing a curriculum that focused on the inner aspects of Torah and would also allow them to gain a livelihood and a sense of self-respect. This is a common theme in R’Kook’s writings, ie that the inner soul of Talmud Torah has been lost and needs to be revitalized with a new curriculum (later posts will entail what R’Kook means by this) that will invigorate and bring out the natural talents of everyone, not just that Talmudic Genius.

One can sense R’Kooks frustration with what he feels is a sense of apathy and indifference to the plight of his generations youth by the leaders of his day. He fails to comprehend the stubborn refusal for a change when clearly one is necessary for the greater good of the nation.


Here is the letter, unabridged:

By the grace of God, the holy city of Jaffa, may it be rebuilt and established 8 Adar 5670 [1910]

Peace and blessing my friend, the renowned rabbi, who is wise and learned, a treasure of Torah and fear of God, our master Rabbi Barukh Meirs, may he live to a long and good life, the head of hte rabbinic tribunal of the holy city of Haifa, may it be rebuilt and established.

Your precious letter reached me. Rabbi Joshua Burak has undoubtedly informed you of our conversation concerning the general condition, and that I wrote him an encouraging letter. May it be God’s will to prosper his efforts to strengthen the knowledge of God and his laws among hte people of Israel in the Holy land.

My dear friend, you called my attention to the station of religion at the present time. What can I say to you, my friend? My heart suffers grievously because of the general situation. There is no one left who represents with dignity the cause of God’s name and his Torah in the Holy Land. The more I brood on this though, the more troubled I feel in my heart and I cannot see an effective way to begin some corrective action. For it is very difficult for me to come to a meeting of minds with most of the leading religious figures of our time, may God watch over them they desire follow the old path solely, to keep themselves at a distance from every creative talent and from all current trends in life. In my opinion, this is the altogether against the way of God. By their attitude they strengthen the hands of the rebels and support the wrongdoers. Alas for the sins of these people, though they are well-intentioned.

I have no alternative but to support the educational efforts which room for the knowledge of the world and of life, and that trains the children to find joy in life, to be strong and brave, to cultivate hygiene and personal dignity. When this training will be combined with training in the Torah and the true fear of God, it will become their adornment and enhance their vitality. In the end even the nonreligious forces will have acknowledge the validity of our position.

Buy what can I do when this approach, which I have no doubt we must follow, has embroiled me in the entanglements of a war from the right and the left? However, I place my hope in God, may his name be praised, taht he will strengthen me to hold on high the banner of truth, that the holy cause be vindicated. And you know, my friend, that these important issues are all interrelated. Most of the scholars of our generation, even the greatest among them, pay no attention cultivating the principles of the fear of God, in a spirit of broadmindedness, as would befit the leaders of the generation. They cannot pursue new paths appropriate for the needs of the time, to direct them toward holiness. In their opinion, they must not veer from the old pattern, refusing to draw on any good element in the new ways, thereby to mend the condition of the generation.

They will not acknowledge, under any circumstances, that they have neglected a basic principle which embraces the whole Torah and all religion.

It is for this reason and the we stumble in the daytime as the blind man stumbles in the dark, and the multitude is astray, they are increasingly alienated from their faith. But they are in sense at fault. Since there is no one to show them the right course, to join the holiness of the Torah and religious faith with life, they are losing their faith. But there are many good elements in them and much sensitivity of spirit, and many among them desire with a full heart the salvation of the people of Israel and of this, their basic goal is rooted in holiness, for the salvation of Israel truly embraces all aspects of holiness. It is for us to judge charitably even the most offending among them, if only he is not willing to defect from our people and join our adversaries.

The more we add positive elements to our education program and teach our children the subject which help a person earn a livelihood and gain self-respect, together with the study of the Torah, the foundation of the Torah will be strengthened and gain in vitality.

But with whom shall I speak, who will agree with me, who is prepared to jeopardize his own honor for the honor of God, praised be he, and of his Torah, and for the holiness of his beloved land?

Let us hope that God will act for his own sake, and inspire the hearts of all the Torah scholars to comprehend the pure way of God and that Israel and Judah will soon find deliverance. And this will be my reward.

My greetings to you as so befits your precious self, and with much love, and in anticipation of God’s help.


Igrot I, Letter 274

R’Kook – Your Independent Intuition

Your Independent Intuition

It is not the intent of any influence that comes from outside yourself and into your inner being–whether from secular or holy sources–to silence your spirit and mute your independent intuition. Rather, its intent is to bathe you with a flow of light, so that you will absorb it into the essence of who you are.
In this way, and from the midst of this, your independent sense will grow ever stronger. When you are desolated by internal shoddiness, you think that the intention of everything that comes from outside yourself is to abrade your independent sense of reality, to make you crumple, and you totter. You become short-tempered and you cease to grow.
Together, the holy and the secular influence your spirit. When you integrate them, you are enriched. You must take what is fitting from each of them. From the holy, take the light of life and an inner character. From the secular, take the container, the superficial understanding that provides a basis for grasping the content. The secular provides material for analogies and explanations, for contexts in which to understand the ways of the world and good character traits.
There is a spirit of abundance that is the awareness of division between the holy and the secular. That abundance becomes ever more clear when you gather the wealth of these various sources. It strengthens and illumines your spirit.At last, you come to the innermost circle of Torah. The diseased cloud within you that hides the Torah begins to glow more and more with the light of Torah. Out of the mist, lights are revealed in their full beauty.

Orot Hakodesh I, pp. 67-68
From the Well of Kindness, Pg 24 hosted at Jewish Spiritual and Beautiful  

Some ideas from Orot Hateshuva by R’ Kook

Here are some beautiful quotes from R’Kooks sefer Orot Hatushuva (Translated by Dr Alter B.Z Metzger, 1978, YU Press). In [brackets], I put my understanding of what R’Kook is saying.

Chapter V, pg 38

"Repentence is the healthiest expierence of the soul. A healthy soul in a healthy body must inevitably attain the great happiness of repentance, and in the this state the soul will feel the greatest natural pleasure. The casting out of the harmful substances exerts its virtuous and healthful effect upon the body when the body is perfect in its character; and the spiritual voiding of every evil deed and all the evil and corrupt impressions caused thereby, of every evil thought, of every withdrawel from the Godly emanent content in general which is the basis of all evil, the casting out of all coarseness and ugliness must inevitably come – when the organism is healthy both in terms of its spiritual and material aspects."

[R’ Kook is comparing the act of teshuva to the process of excretion by the human body. A normal human body has a desire to get rid of all its waste, (waste being a symbol of a  persons sins) to cleanse and purify itself so that it can continue to function. If a body does not desire to get rid of its waste you would say the body is sick and not functioning. So too with teshuva, if a person does not wish to get rid of their sins and allows the sins to corrupt and pollute their soul, you would say that person is "sick" and not healthy. Hence every normal person should have a desire and will to perform teshuva as it is an innately natural process that is fundamental to our existence]

Chapter VII, pg 45

"It is the nature of repentance to give unto man peace and oppressiveness of mind simultaneously. Man is consoled with even the slightest thought of repentance, within one small point of its great light there rests already the lofty and exalted happiness of an entire univserse. At the same time, it constantly places before the eyes of his spirit the obligations of fulfillment, which save him from arrogance and cast upon him a sweet light, giving great and constant value to his lift.

The concept of reprentance transforms all inquities and their confusion, their spiritual suffering and their ugliness, into conceptions of happiness and contentment because, by measns of the inquities, there emanates unto man the profound knowledge of hatred for evil, and love of virtue grows stronger within him with noble strength. Beyond all reckoning and knowledge, he derives from the joy of solace the Divine pleasure which is solely for those who have repented. Most pleasurable of all is this feeling when joined with the refining sense of a broken heart and contrite soul, a soul united with deep faith in redemptions and enternal salvation"

[R’ Kook is saying that the nature of teshuva is paradoxical. On the one hand it gives on a sense of relief and peace of mind (because you have escaped punishment), yet on the the hand it leaves one feeling "oppressed". I would imagine this feeling comes from the fact that although you have repented and asked forgiveness for ones sins and will therefore not be punished, there is still a void that you feel is left within you – You are troubled how you could have steeped to such a low, and even if the sin is forgiven, you yourself feel that it is not forgotten (expecially by yourself or by other people involved, never mind in the eyes of G-d). However R’Kook is saying that it is that precise feeling that makes your teshuva genuine. These feelings will cause you to forever feel humbled, constantly watching yourself.  You will be keept from arrogance for you know that you are not a saint and have sinned, but yet these feelings allow you to carry on growing because you are constantly reminding youself and trying to rectify your personality so that these deeds will not occur in the future.]

The Relationship between R’Kook and the Chofetz Chaim: Part 2

Below are two extracts taken from the “The Chafetz Chaim” (Rabbi Moses M. Yosher, Artscroll History Series, that should highlight the relationship that existed between R’Kook and the Chofetz Chaim.

[Pg 161 – Pg 162]

Many a prominent personage in religious Jewry could give credit for his successful career and honour achievement to the influence of the Chafetz Chaim. Suffice it to mention that such a renowned figure of distinction as the first chief rabbi of the Land of Israel, Rav Avraham Yitzchak Hakohen Kook, would relate with particular pleasure, how he agreed, under the influence of Chafetz Chaim himself, to give up his plan to go into a career in commerce and instead to prepare to become a rabbi.

It is interesting to note that Rav Kook, then a young man, as first argued with the Chafetz Chaim that peraparation for the rabbinate would prevent him from fulfilling a previous commitment. He had promised the Chafetz Chaim, at his request that a Kohen he would choose an area of study in the laws of Temple sacrifice and learn it thoroughly enough to be able to clarify these unused laws, perhaps for a time of future observance. How could he keep his promise and still study for the rabbinate? The Chafetz Chaim responded by saying that he would release him, so long as he undertook to become a rabbi.[1]

[1] The Chafetz Chaim spent a great amount of time in Torah study with the young Rav Kook at that time. Ever since then, the pious sage greatly esteemed and honoured him

[Pg 440 – 442]
An Excellent evaluation of the Chafetz Chaim as a man of halacha was given by Rav Avraham Yitzchak HaKohen Kook (in HaHeid, Jerusalem, Tishrei 1934). He wrote:

His first creation, from which his own name was established for all time, was the sacred book Chofetz Chaim. In it he gives the laws of the prohibitions on evil tongue and slander, with all their details, in a precise, organized manner, with a marvelous and valuable introduction. It is all clear-cut, definitive halacha, set on a firm basis of sources from Babylonian and Jerusalem Talmuds, Tosefta, Sifra, Sifre and the definitive law of the Rishonim. With all this we have his straightforward elucidation which show how he derived all his conclusions from a halachic foundation. The subject of Evil Tongue brings pain to ones moral sensibility, but he did not assuage the pain by just preaching. Rather, he set everything on a foundation of sound halacha. Only in a few instance does some expression of moral outrage escape from his heart, directed at the deformity of speech which we call Evil Tongue, common in the world, to our great sorrow.

Much later, after this sacred volume spread in halachic circles, he thought it proper to publish a book of ethics full of pure mussar, true Torah and fear of Heaven, a book that is based essentially on the moral aspect of clean speech. The book, Shmiras Halashon, is a book in which every expression reminds us of the early masters of mussar, those men of great soul, the geonim and tzaddikim for all generations.

It was the holiness of kindness, of chessed, so firmly rooted in his heart, that impelled him to write his excellent book Ahavas Chesed. It is virtually in the same format as his Chafetz Chaim, a compendium of laws, clear and pertinent, on all aspects of kindness, chesd. This, too, is a halachic work, addressing its subject in the precise mode Jewish Law.

His heart, was full of concern for the welfare of Judaism in distance places where the Jewish community was not yet as well established. With special insight, he understood the trials that immigrants to new lands had to face in assuring the preservation of their full religious life. For that reason, he published his book Nidchei Yisrael. The book is filled with specific halachas that address the condition facing emerging communities in distant land. He sought to strengthen and encourage them, and to give them the heart to overcome all obstacles and to defend with all their might the completeness of their Judaism.

His vision penetrated to what was happening to Jewish youth, expecially to young men who were conscripted into armies where they were compelled to live lives removed from all Judaism. They needed special guidance on how to maintain their Judaism even in situations of military stress and of alien yokes that would bear down on them with force. For these Jewish soldiers, he wrote Machaneh Yisrael.

All the time, he was sensitive to the need for a full Jewish life, a life of Torah and Mitzvos, This is the Jewish life that is fixed and lasting, the Jewish life that is defined in all its details in the code of law, the Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chaim. He found that although it had been explained and elucidated and commented upon by the great scholars of each generation, who unremittingly negated themselves in the task, there were still unfulfilled needs. With the immensity of halachic detail, there were many Jews who required clarification and determination of practical halacha. For this reason, he wrote Mishnah Berurah, and the accompanying Biur Halacha, both explaining, even to the reader of mild erudition, how to live by the Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chaim. This book, Mishna Berurah, particularly gained its place among the Jews as a definitive work whose decisions were followed everywhere, a timeless heritage for them.

When the messianic Redemption comes, speedily in our day, and the Bais HaMikdash is built anew, the entiree body of Torah law concerning holy offerings will have to be clearly and lucidly available especially for the Kohanim [who will have to minister and attend to the offerings at the Sanctuary]. That tzaddik, however saw that this field of study was utterly neglected, and so het set his mighty hand to task and wrote a major work, Likkutei Halachos, on the entire Talmudic order Kodashim… in the format of the compendium of Rav Yitzchak Alfasi on the Babylonian Talmud.

Update on R’Kook letter

It seems that the letter from the son in law of the Chofetz Chaim to R’ Kook has received a lot of interest. For that I am glad, because I feel that there are many myths circulating the Orthodox world on a variety of issues that need to dispelled. If by publishing this letter on my blog I have brought light onto this delicate subject, I feel I have fulfilled my duty.

I received an interesting email the other day from a gentleman requesting a copy of the original Hebrew letter. Lo and behold, it turns out that he is a great grandson of R’ Aharon Hakohen (the son in law of the CC, who authored this letter). I asked him to share some insights or some stories he had heard regarding his great grandfather. This is what he responded:

I guess the most interesting thing I heard was that when the arabs
controlled Har Hazeisim, they desecrated most of the kvaros; one of the few
they were too scared to touch was that of R. Aharon Hakohen.

B"H, his seforim have been reprinted and are being studied again, especially
"Avodas Hakorbanos", which has been divided into "limud yomi". Kohanim
worldwide are encouraged to study it in preparation of the avoda returning,
BMH"B, Amen.

Is not the works of providence amazing? Here we are in the year 2005, and a great grandson of the author of a letter published in 1928 finds it online on this very blog, that is 77 years later. To the best of my knowledge he had not been aware of this letter until now. Absolutely mind blowing stuff, at least to me anyway.

Letter from the Son in Law of the Chofetz Chaim to Rav Kook (1928)

In a recent post of mine to Areivim I presented alleged evidence of the Chofetz Chaim making disparaging statements regarding R’ Kook. I was personally upset over this evidence, hence the reason for sending it into Areivim to see what other people thought of it. A poster on Areivim (David Hojda) was kind of enough to respond to my post and sent me a letter from Rav Aharon HaKohen (son in law of the Chofetz Chaim) to R’ Kook. It was in hebrew (please email me if you want to receive a copy of the original hebrew). A good friend of this blog Chardal (http://www.chardal.blogspot.com) was kind enough to translate this letter for me. Below is the contents of this letter which I think is a very strong piece of evidence regarding the relationship between R’Kook and the Chofetz Chaim, and hopefully will have the potential to dispel many myths. It is interesting to note this letter was written in  1928, which is eight years after the publication of Orot (1920) which was one of R’ Kooks most controversial works and also after he become Chief Rabbi of the Medina in 1921 (another controversial period in the life of R’Kook). For further details see [http://www.geocities.com/m_yericho/ravkook/timeline.htm] for a timeline of the life of R’ Kook. Many thanks once again to Chardal for translating the letter and to David Hojda for originally sending it to me.

Rav Aharon HaKohen
Author of the book ‘Avodat HaKorbanot’
Son in law of the Gaon Israel Meir HaKohen Shlit”a author of the book Chafetz Chaim and Mishna Brura
Tel Aviv, Eretz Yisrael

With Hashem’s help, 5688 (1928)

Even though my heart was always greatly pained when people who claim to be observant of Torah and mitzvoth dare to disparage the brilliant and righteous, pious and modest, leader of the land of Israel, our teacher Avraham Yitzchak HaKohen Kook Shlit”a – I refrained from public protest regarding the honor of the Torah. [This is because] I know that my master and teacher, the Chafetz Chaim Shlit”a – who honors and is very fond of the honorable Gaon Avraham Yitzchak HaKohen Shlit”a and whose heart was greatly sickened when he heard of the persecutions against [the Rav] – did not come out with public rebuke regarding this, saying that silence regarding such matters and the reduction of their publicity is [the proper way] to repair them – [that is] to lessen and reduce their value. (nevertheless, no one dares utter words of disparagement against our teacher Rav Avaraham Yitzchak HaKohen Shlit”a in front of our master[, the Chafetz Chaim,] and he would turn his eyes with contempt from any posters [disparaging Rav Kook -ed]).

However, when I recently saw that a periodical that has appeared – which arrogantly dares to call itself “meeting place of the sages” – wrote horrible, cursed, and blasphemous words against our teacher Rav Avaraham Yitzchak HaKohen Shlit”a – [words which] are forbidden to even put in print – I find it a holy obligation in my soul not to be silent (as is explicit in the Rambam הלכות ת"ת פ"ו הל’ יא-יב). [This is because] someone who disparages a Torah scholar has no portion in the world to come, and is in the category of one who “despises the Word of Hashem” (כי דבר ה’ בזה), and we are obligated to banish him. [And this is especially true regarding] this brilliant and pious [rav] – that it is forbidden to remain silent [on this matter] and we must go out and rebuke this humiliation of the Torah, and join ourselves to the protest and great anger of the rabbis and sages of the Holy Land and the exile regarding these words of villainy. [Thus] we should not see [that which is] Holy destroyed, G-d Forbid.

And may Hashem, may His Name be Blessed, remove the disgrace from the children of Israel and raise the honor of our Holy Torah. These are the words [of one] who writes with a wounded and agitated heart regarding the honor of our holy Torah which is [being] given over to disgrace.

Aharon HaKohen
Son in law of the brilliant Rav, the righteous Chafetz Chaim, Shlit”a